The historical information buried in the U.S. patent collection is always surprising. U.S. Patent No. D41551 issued July 11, 1911, on a badge, button, or similar article:
The assignee of this design for a button explains the letters NATL – the National Anti-Tipping League. The National Anti-Tipping League was a domestic nonprofit corporation to oppose the practice of tipping, which had become a point of cultural and political debate in the early 20th century.
Tipping in the U.S. began after the Civil War, when wealthy Americans returning from Europe adopted the aristocratic European custom of rewarding servants with small coins. This was seen by many Americans as a sign of class distinctions and anti-democratic behavior. By the 1890’s opposition had grown into a Great Anti-Tipping Crusade. Anti-tipping groups declared tipping “un-American” and “a cancer” claiming it created artificial class systems, undermined fair wages, and allowed employers to pay below-living wages while shifting responsibility to customers. Some states even banned tipping in certain industries.
The ‘551 patent issued at the height of the anti-tipping movement. But, as we are acutely aware in 2026, tipping persisted and became embedded in American culture. The National Anti-Tipping League was a small part of a larger, ultimately successful movement. 115 years later, the debate on tipping in the U.S. is reemerging as tipping is being forced upon us nearly everywhere.