Motivation to Combine Turns on the Invention’s Objective, Not the Prior Art’s Purpose

In In re Netlist, [2025-1286, 2025-1296] (November 13, 2026), the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the PTAB determination that U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and
9,858,215 to be unpatentable as obvious.

Netlist did not dispute that the combination of prior art discloses the claim limitations of
the patents, but argued that a person of ordinary skill lacked motivation to combine the references because the combination would make the Perego reference inoperable for its intended purpose, and would eliminate the key benefits of the Perego reference.

After noting that motivation to combine is a question of fact reviewed for substantial evidence, the Federal Circuit said that Netlist misconceives the law of obviousness. As the Supreme Court noted in KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., “familiar items may have obvious uses beyond their primary purposes, and in many cases a person of ordinary skill will be able to fit the teachings of multiple patents together like pieces of a puzzle.” The Federal Circuit said that when an obviousness challenge asserts a combination of identified prior art, the motivation-to-combine portion of the inquiry is whether a skilled artisan would have been motivated to combine the teachings of the prior art references to achieve the claimed invention, citing Axonics, Inc. v. Medtronic, Inc., 73 F.4th 950, 957 (Fed. Cir. 2023). The Court quoted that “[t]he inquiry is not whether a relevant artisan would combine a first reference’s feature with a second reference’s feature to meet requirements of the first reference that are not requirements of the claims at issue.”

The Court said it has often confirmed that in a motivation-to-combine analysis, “the intended purpose of [the prior art] does not control.” E.g., Intel Corp. v. Qualcomm Inc., 21 F.4th 784,
800 (Fed. Cir. 2021). The Court said that what matters is whether a skilled artisan would have had an adequate reason to modify Perego. The Federal Circuit said that compatibility with Rambus was not the purpose of the claimed invention, and backward compatibility was
not an objective of the claimed invention. The fact that the combination was not compatible with Rambus and would not serve the backward-compatibility objectives of Perego is irrelevant.

The Federal Circuit acknowledged that there are limited circumstances where the purpose of the prior art device is pertinent; for example, where the alleged motivation to combine comes from the functionality of the invention disclosed in the prior art publication, rather than from another source. When a prior-art reference itself supplies the asserted motivation to combine, it is logical to assume that the reference would not suggest to a POSA to modify its disclosed embodiments in a way that contravenes its own contemplated purposes.

The Federal Circuit said that the purpose of the prior art may also be relevant where the prior art has a “purpose [that is] shared with the challenged claims.” Medtronic, Inc. v. Teleflex Innovations S.à.r.l., 69 F.4th 1341, 1350 (Fed. Cir. 2023). However the instant case was not a situation where the defeated purpose was a shared purpose, as in cases such as Polaris Industries, Inc. v. Arctic Cat, Inc., 882 F.3d 1056 (Fed. Cir. 2018) or Medtronic.

The Court said that Netlist argues only that the proposed combination is inoperable for Perego’s intended purposes, not the purposes of the claimed invention as in Polaris, Medtronic, and Chemours. The Court concluded that Netlist does not argue that Perego supplied the motivation to combine. Thus, the Board did not err by finding a motivation to combine.